A VERY DANGEROUS TREND

(Freedom of Speech: Norman Rockwell Museum, Stockbridge, MA)

 

There is a very dangerous trend in the United States that unfortunately seems to be spreading — a trend toward denying those with whom one disagrees the right to speak.

It has popped up in news stories from here and there and from time to time in the last few years.  I was reminded of it again a few days ago, when while walking through a neighborhood shopping district, I began to notice posters advertising a public lecture.

The problem however, was that the posters were not just informing the public of the lecture; instead, they were encouraging people to appear at the lecture and “shut it down,” so that the lecturer would not be able to give his presentation.

This an extremely dangerous and virulent form of censorship.  Without freedom of speech — the open marketplace of ideas — a free society cannot long exist.  It is only natural to oppose views that we may consider wrong or even abhorrent, but we must be very cautious and sensible in how we oppose them.  Preventing the public expression of those views by “shutting down” lectures, or by intimidating speakers, or by somehow getting speakers banned (yes, this has shockingly even happened on college campuses lately) only leads to the loss of freedom of speech for everyone, because no matter what ideas a person may have, one will find others who disagree with them.

The right way to deal with ideas one abhors is to use your own freedom of speech to oppose them — not with violence or intimidation or banning, but with facts and evidence and rational persuasion — and of course the vote.

The right to freely and publicly express one’s ideas is a hard-won privilege born out of centuries of violent religious and political persecution and bloodshed.  No sensible person would want to turn the clock back to the equivalent of the Spanish Inquisition or Nazi Germany, but those who advocate only permitting the public expression of ideas with which they agree, and encourage “shutting down” any public speech with which they strongly disagree, are unwittingly advocating and working toward the return of such a Dark Age. It is the height of foolishness and irresponsibility, and unworthy of a democratic society.

Deny one person free speech today, and you endanger everyone’s right to free speech — your own included — tomorrow.

 

David

 

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “A VERY DANGEROUS TREND

  1. So true. While I believe it’s wrong to incite violence against other people, to speak about what we believe is right or wrong should be a given in any free society. What’s happening today sounds more like, “If you don’t agree with me, you’re ‘hateful’ and hateful people should be silenced.”

  2. Dear David,

    Thank you for your important statement on free speech (https://hokku.wordpress.com/2018/06/08/a-very-dangerous-trend/). I agree with everything you write except for the way you lump together nazism and the inquisition; I can assure you that the two are in no way related. I humbly suggest that you and your readers view and/or read the transcript of “The Inquisition,” which can be found at https://www.churchmilitant.com/video/episode/the-inquisition ; this piece is very informative because it’s well researched.

    All the best to you.

    Claude

  3. James Donado

    David,

    I read your posts for discussion of hokku and other poetry. Hokku, along with other hobbies of mine, provide not only personal development, but also escape from other aspects of daily life, including politics. Though I strongly agree shutting down an opposing side in an argument is not a good idea, I do not seek such discussions when I visit this site.

    Respectfully,

    Jim Donado

    REPLY:

    To me, freedom of speech is not politics; it is essential to a free, literary society, and to personal education and development. I consider it an important, crucial issue. So though I avoid politics here, I will continue, when it seems appropriate, to discuss free speech and issues that affect Nature and the environment. The percentage of such postings here to the whole is extremely small (though given what is happening in the world and to the climate, it should probably be larger), and the solution for those who do not wish to read such postings is of course simply not to read them. I very much appreciate all readers here, but I also maintain the freedom to choose my topics.

    David

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.